WILD vs FARMED SALMON

Surveying an early fishing boat, Kogguing, Alaska

In the same way that is impossible to compare free-range beef or un-caged chicken with feedlot-penned, industrially produced livestock, it is impossible to compare the firm, resilient texture of wild salmon flesh with the flesh of farmed salmon. Wild salmon undertake a phenomenal 1200 to 1500 to sometimes 2000-mile journey, from freshwater lakes and pools that serve as nurseries to distant Pacific and Arctic salt waters. The taste, natural oils, and muscular tone that wild salmon develop on this journey make wild sockeye incomparable to penned fish.

Although sockeye salmon are never farmed commercially, because they have proven practically impossible to spawn in controlled situations; other varieties of salmon have been increasingly farmed over the past 15 years. Farmed salmon have given rise to a number of environmental and health concerns-particularly the tendency of fish farms to disrupt local ecosystems and the dangerous levels of PCBs found in farmed salmon.

A study published in a 2004 issue of Science, a leading scientific journal, concluded that PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls-a persistent chemical compound common to industrial waste) are harmfully concentrated in farmed salmon. Farmed salmon are normally fed a meal composed of mulched feeder fish, a meal that has been found to be high in PCBs. Individual feeder fish accrue minute amounts of PCBs that become harmfully concentrated when fish meal is prepared. According to a year 2000 report by the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, PCBs are "reasonably expected" to cause cancer.

Equally concerning is the tendency of fish farms to foul local ecosystems. Fish farms unnaturally concentrate migratory fish in a very small area. This concentration dirties the area with the feces of thousands of caged fish, an area unequipped to break down such an accumulation. Additionally, these penned fish tend to steal food that belongs to indigenous fish, disrupting the local food chain. The reverberation of these disruptions often destroys healthy, local ecologies.

The bottom line is simple: stay away from farmed salmon, and, always ask, "Is it wild?"





© ALL RIGHTS RESERVED ILIAMNA FISH CO. 2010